The quiet community of Orting, Washington, was shaken to its core when Nicole White, a devoted mother of two, vanished after an evening out. She had done everything right: she met her date in a crowded bar, she checked in with her family, and she stayed in public spaces. Yet, behind the “rugged country boy” persona of Jonathan Harris lay a darkness that no one could have seen coming. This story follows the tireless efforts of the Pierce County Sheriff’s Department as they sift through staged crime scenes and blatant lies.