Staunton was a quiet southern town where everyone felt safe until the night of April 11, 1967. The brutal execution of two young sisters-in-law at a local ice cream parlor sent shockwaves through the community and left families searching for answers that wouldn’t come for over forty years. This story follows the agonizing journey of Carol Smootz, who lived in the shadow of his sister’s unsolved murder while the real killer walked the same streets he did